KITCHEN MASTERS

Budget and process

How to Compare Kitchen Remodel Contractor Proposals

Updated November 19, 2026

Proposals from different contractors for the same kitchen can differ by tens of thousands of dollars. Much of the gap usually comes from differences in what each proposal includes, not from differences in price for the same work.

This guide explains what a complete proposal contains and how to compare several of them on equal terms. Licensing rules, required contract terms, deposit limits and lien laws differ from state to state. The state contractor licensing board or consumer protection office publishes the rules that apply locally, and an attorney can review a contract for a large project.

Giving every contractor the same information

Bids can only be compared when they are based on the same project. Before requesting proposals, prepare a short package and give the same one to each contractor:

  • A floor plan or cabinet layout, even a preliminary one, with dimensions
  • A written list of the work: what is being removed, replaced, moved or kept
  • The intended product level for cabinets, countertops, flooring, tile and fixtures, with specific products where they are known
  • Appliance models, or at least the types and sizes
  • Who supplies what. State whether the homeowner or the contractor buys the appliances, fixtures and tile.
  • The preferred timing and any constraints on working hours

What a complete proposal includes

SectionWhat to look for
Scope of workA room-by-room or trade-by-trade description specific enough that a third party could tell what is included
Materials and productsBrand, model, material, size and finish where selected. Allowance amounts where not.
ExclusionsA stated list of what is not included, such as painting, appliance installation or repairs to hidden damage
PriceA fixed price or a clearly defined cost-plus arrangement, with a breakdown by category if available
Payment scheduleDeposit and progress payments tied to completed stages
ScheduleEstimated start date, duration and what the dates depend on
PermitsWho obtains and pays for permits and arranges inspections
Change ordersA requirement that changes be written, priced and signed before the work is done
WarrantyLength and coverage of the workmanship warranty, plus manufacturer warranties
Insurance and licenseLicense number and proof of liability and workers' compensation coverage
Cleanup and protectionDust control, daily cleanup, debris removal and protection of floors

A one-page proposal with a single total and a few lines of description does not give enough information to compare or to enforce.

Comparing scope and allowances line by line

Put the proposals side by side in a simple spreadsheet with one row for each element of the work: demolition, framing, plumbing, electrical, drywall, flooring, cabinets, countertops, backsplash, paint, appliances and installation, permits and cleanup. Enter what each proposal says for each row, and mark the rows where a proposal is silent.

Then ask each contractor about the gaps. Typical differences are whether the electrical price includes new circuits or a panel upgrade, whether drywall repair and painting are included, whether the cabinet price includes crown molding, panels and hardware, and who installs the appliances.

Check the allowances. An allowance is a placeholder amount for items not yet selected. One proposal may allow 3 dollars per square foot for tile and another 12. Adjust the totals to a common allowance, or make the selections, so that the comparison reflects the same products. Unusually low allowances are a common reason that the lowest bid is not the lowest final cost.

License, insurance and reference checks

  • License: verify the license or registration number on the state or local licensing board's website, and check that it is current and covers this type of work.
  • Insurance: ask for certificates of general liability insurance and workers' compensation coverage, sent directly by the insurer or agent.
  • Trade licenses: confirm that electrical, plumbing and gas work will be done by licensed tradespeople under permits.
  • Lead-safe certification: for homes built before 1978, firms that disturb painted surfaces must be certified under the federal lead renovation rule.
  • References: speak with two or three recent customers with similar projects. Useful questions cover whether the price held, how changes were handled, how clean the site was kept and whether the crew returned for repairs.
  • Complaints and legal history: check the licensing board's complaint records.

Payment schedule and contract terms

Payments should follow progress. A typical structure is a deposit at signing, several progress payments tied to defined stages such as completion of rough-in, cabinet installation and countertop installation, and a final payment of about 5 to 10 percent held until the punch list is complete and final inspections have passed.

Deposits of 10 to 30 percent are common, partly to cover cabinet orders, and some states cap the deposit by law. A request for most of the price in advance, or for payment in cash only, is a warning sign.

Ask how the contractor handles lien releases. In most states, subcontractors and suppliers who are not paid can place a lien on the property even when the homeowner has paid the general contractor. Signed lien waivers collected with each payment protect against this. The contract should also state how disputes are resolved and under what conditions either party can end the agreement.

Change orders, schedule and warranty

Changes during construction are normal. Hidden damage may be found, or the homeowner may alter a selection. The contract should require that each change be described in writing with its price and its effect on the schedule, and signed by both parties before the work proceeds. Ask what markup applies to change orders.

A schedule in a proposal is an estimate, but it should exist. Ask what the start date depends on, how many projects the firm runs at once, and who will be on site each day. A workmanship warranty of at least one year is common, and some contractors offer longer terms. Ask how warranty requests are made and how quickly they are usually handled.

Common mistakes when comparing proposals

  • Choosing by the bottom-line total without comparing scope
  • Accepting vague wording such as install new kitchen per plan with no specifications
  • Overlooking low allowances
  • Not verifying the license and insurance directly
  • Agreeing to work without permits to save time or money
  • Paying a large deposit or paying ahead of completed work
  • Relying on verbal promises that are not written into the contract
  • Skipping reference calls
  • Signing under time pressure, such as a discount that expires the same day

Frequently asked questions

How many contractor proposals should be compared?

Three is the usual recommendation. It gives enough range to see what is typical for the project and to spot a proposal that is missing scope or is priced unusually high or low.

Why do kitchen remodel bids differ so much?

Mostly because they are not pricing the same thing. Differences in scope, product quality, allowances, exclusions and overhead explain most of the gap. Lining up the proposals row by row usually shows where the difference lies.

How much deposit is reasonable for a kitchen remodel?

Deposits of 10 to 30 percent are common, often linked to the cabinet order. Some states set a legal maximum, so check the rules published by the state contractor licensing board. The remaining payments should be tied to completed stages.

What is the difference between an estimate and a fixed-price proposal?

An estimate is an approximate cost that can change. A fixed-price proposal commits the contractor to a stated price for a defined scope, with changes handled by written change orders. Cost-plus contracts charge actual costs plus a fee and need clear records and limits.

Should the lowest bid be chosen?

Not automatically. A low bid may reflect missing scope, low allowances or thin insurance coverage. After the proposals have been adjusted to the same scope, the remaining difference can be weighed against each contractor's references, communication and schedule.

Further reading